Health and Safety Consultancy Services for SMEs in Birmingham, West Midlands and beyond

OFSTED inspector kicks off a health and safety row
Posted by David Cant on August 17, 2017

OFSTED inspector kicks off a health and safety row

old school signIn this day and age, it is rare to hear a civil servant calling for children to be exposed to risky situations. But when Ofsted chief Amanda Spielman accused schools of mollycoddling students, that’s exactly what seemed to happen – or so the tabloid headlines would have you believe.

Spielman claims that headteachers are unable to distinguish between ‘real and imagined risk’. This leads many teachers to avoid learning experiences that leaving kids unskilled in the area of personal responsibility – and potentially depriving them of many enjoyable experiences growing up.

Her comments were quite cutting;

Trying to insulate your pupils from every bump, germ or bruise, won’t just drive you to distraction, it will short change those pupils as well – limiting their opportunity to fully take advantage of the freedom of childhood, and to explore the world around them.

Taking health and safety responsibilities too far?

Spielman’s statements have caused outrage in some quarters, with teachers’ unions sharply criticising the advice. One anonymous source said, ‘Surely parents are the people who can take risks with their own children and not those entrusted to keep them safe.

The Health and Safety at Work Act requires employers and responsible parties to take all reasonable steps to reduce risk of injury under their control. Which means safeguarding against actual dangers. It does not, as Spielman points out, require protections against imagined threats.

In her own example, Spielman suggests that although children should be closely supervised when walking to school, there is no need to make them wear a hi-vis vest. There are dangers inherent in walking along the road – but they are well known and managed. The hi-vis vest is an unnecessary additional protection against an imagined risk.

Real and imaginary risks in the workplace

In the workplace, there is a need to balance health and safety obligations, and profitability. Unnecessary spend on safeguards increases costs and eats into profit margins.

And if legislation only requires you to protect against genuine risks, everything else is a waste of time, effort and money.

This realisation is liberating and dangerous. Businesses are free to reduce spending on unnecessary safeguards – but they can go too far. It is absolutely essential that comprehensive risk assessments are undertaken for every activity on site, identifying the very real dangers present. But it is then incumbent on the employer to take those findings and act upon them.

Simply deciding that a perceived risk “isn’t too bad” is no justification for failing to implement measures to protect workers. And if there is any doubt about whether a risk is real or imagined, employers must seek professional advice, or they could be placing their workers in danger.

Amanda Spielman has raised an important topic for teachers and employers with potentially long-term consequences. It will be interesting to see if anyone heeds her concerns.

To learn more about health and safety risk assessments, and sorting real risks from imagined, please get in touch.


Director at Veritas Consulting. The SME's favourite go-to consultant for health and safety know-how. Bucket loads of experience. Fluent in practical advice. Solutionist with a brain you can pick.

You can find him across Social media - Twitter and Facebook also Linkedin

This post has been filed in: Blog


  1. Chris George
    August 31, 2017 at 10:12 am

    This is a bugbear of mine. How are kids supposed to learn about making mistakes if they’re deprived of the oppurtunity. If my child cuts him or herself on kitchen knife cutting bread, they’d try not to do it again because it hurts. It’s all part of growing up.

    • August 31, 2017 at 1:08 pm

      I agree Chris. Children need to be risk aware and not risk averse. Helps with their development for issues that they will face in later life.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *


(Spamcheck Enabled)

Latest Blog Posts
Health and safety advice from a UN weapons inspector Health and safety advice from a UN weapons inspector A UN weapons inspector may be used to working with bioweapons – but their health... Read More
Finally! The Supreme Court resolves tribunal confusion Supreme Court finally resolves tribunal confusion A recent decision by the Supreme Court should help to reduce time and cost of overturning an incorrect... Read More
Lessons from history – the Sampoong department store disaster Lessons from history – the Sampoong department store disaster The collapse of a department store building 28 years ago still has lessons for construction... Read More
Follow all of the latest Veritas Consulting news on our RSS feed